For Europe, a lesson in ABCs (of Cyrillic)

The New York Times

SOFIA — When Saints Cyril and Methodius gave the Slavic world its first written script, their mission was to draw the Slavs under the influence of Constantinople and away from Rome. A thousand or so years later, Cyrillic is heading west – this time to a united Europe.

With Bulgaria scheduled to enter the European Union along with Romania on Jan. 1, Cyrillic is becoming the bloc’s third official alphabet, after Latin and Greek; by the end of the decade, if Bulgaria succeeds in joining the euro zone, it may even appear on euro banknotes.

Although Bulgaria has no commitment to reciprocate by displaying signs in the Latin alphabet, “We are doing it,” says Nikolay Vassilev, minister for state administration and administrative reform. “More slowly than I would like.”

With one of the world’s largest translation services, the EU does not expect problems adding Bulgarian and its Cyrillic alphabet to the array of languages it already handles.

Still, linguistic diversity comes at a price. For 2005, the total cost of all language services – written translation and spoken interpretation – in the EU’s 20 official languages was €1.1 billion – about 1 percent the total EU budget, or €2.28 per person across the 25-member bloc. With the addition of Bulgarian and Romanian in 2007, along with Irish becoming an operational language, the cost is expected to increase by a total of €30 million, or $38.5 million. The directorate-general for translation will need about 60 full-time translators for each of the three new languages – 180 jobs.

The directorate, based in Luxembourg and Brussels, is already the European Commission’s largest department, with about 1,650 full-time translators and 550 support staff members. In 2005, they translated 1,324,231 pages.

About a third of all EU documents are translated into each official language; the rest, largely internal documents, are translated into the EU’s three working languages: English, French and German.

Rusana Bardarska, a Bulgarian translator, said the hardest part of introducing Bulgarian was EU terminology, for which Bulgarian words may not exist. “Should we translate ‘communitarization,’ ‘convergence,’ ‘flexsecurity’ and ‘cohesion,’ or rather introduce them as new words in Bulgarian?” she asked.

“The alphabet is the easy part,” said Dieter Rummel, head of language technology at the Translations Center for the Bodies of the European Union. “But it was a big deal 10 years ago.”

When the Greek alphabet was first introduced, Rummel said, the available technology could not smoothly accommodate the new character set. But EU computers now use Unicode, a character encoding system that allows representation of all alphabets, even non-Indo- European alphabets such as Chinese.

Back in Bulgaria, however, spelling is a major problem, according to Vassilev, the government minister. Many Cyrillic letters have no Latin equivalent, or several possibilities. The result, he says, is that some Bulgarian cities are spelled seven different ways in Latin – even on signs within the same city.

“There is no other country in the world with a problem of this magnitude,” Vassilev said.

To address this, Vassilev developed “Comprehensible Bulgaria,” a transliteration system created by linguists so that all Bulgarian proper names would be rendered the same way in the Latin alphabet. The transliteration software is available for free on the ministry’s Web page.

The new spellings are now obligatory for state institutions, but people are free to continue transliterating their names as they like, and Vassilev expects it to take years for the public to adopt the new system.

He himself has used four different spellings of his own name during his lifetime. If the cabinet accepts his proposal to make name changing an administrative act rather than a court procedure, he will change his name to conform with the new system: Vasilev.

In Sofia, the capital, street signs differ in each area. Signs for streets named after Communist-era heroes coexist with the signs bearing new post-Communist street names. Some neighborhoods have signs in Cyrillic only, while others have Latin signs as well.

“Until now, neighborhood mayors who have wanted to change the signs have changed them however they have wanted,” says Velizar Stoilov, deputy mayor for transport and transport infrastructure. He is working on a project to replace and unify the city’s 800,000 or so street signs on the occasion of Bulgaria’s EU entry. All would be bilingual, with the spellings defined by the new system. Informational signs for tourist sites in English would also be included.

Since the city cannot afford the estimated cost of €4 million, EU accession funds are a possible source of finance, Stoilov said.

Visitors to Sofia have mixed impressions of the linguistic challenge. While they are glad to have maps in the Latin alphabet, some say, this does not help much when street signs are in Cyrillic.

“If I want to find where I am on the map, I have to count the number of streets,” said Stanley Tam, a bus operator from Ottawa.

Chantal Bonnin, a surgeon from Bordeaux, disagreed, saying she liked signs in Cyrillic only, even though it took her family two hours to find their hotel. “If they write like us, it’s a problem of the unification of languages,” she said. “Otherwise, in 30 years, there will be only one.”

Vassilev says he has no concerns about the survival of Bulgarian as a language, at least not as a result of accession to the European Union.

“Joining the EU has less of an effect on Cyrillic than globalization, the Internet and SMSs,” he said.

For Bulgarian-language Internet communication and SMS exchanges, young Bulgarians have improvised a new Latin-based alphabet, largely because of the convenience of using Latin text interfaces.

Bulgarians are so proud of their alphabet that they celebrate a national holiday on May 24 called “the Day of Bulgarian Enlightenment and Culture and of the Slavonic Alphabet.” The holiday was created in the mid-19th century, when Bulgaria was trying to become independent after 500 years as part of the Turkish Ottoman Empire.

“The holiday was a good solution to separate Bulgaria from the Turks and away from Catholic Christian world,” says Christo Matanov, professor of medieval bulgarian history at Sofia University. “The main task was building a modern nation.”

The Cyrillic alphabet is used by 224 million people in Russia, Ukraine, Belarus, Bulgaria, Macedonia, Montenegro, Serbia and Bosnia (in Montenegro, Serbia and Bosnia, the Latin alphabet is used, too). An additional 60 million Central Asians use Cyrillic to write their own non-Slavic languages, though the Soviet-era linguistic leftover is being phased out.

That Bulgaria “gave” the alphabet to the Slavs is hotly disputed by five other Slavic nations – Macedonia, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Ukraine, and Russia – as well as Greece.

The Bulgarian claim is based on the alphabet’s taking hold, developing, and spreading mostly within the territory of what was then the Bulgarian Empire.

It is no surprise, then, that Bulgaria, planning to join the zone of countries using the euro as currency in 2009 or 2010, wants the word “euro” to be written in Cyrillic on bank notes, as it already is in Latin and Greek.

The European Central Bank is planning to consider integrating the new alphabet in a series of euro banknotes to be issued by the end of this decade.



In Bulgaria, a fleeced public is left in cold

The New York Times

SOFIA — The director of the Sofia central heating company might not have a glamorous job. The company, a Soviet- era behemoth, is more than €50 million in debt and is owed €80 million by customers unable or unwilling to pay their heating bills. The pay for the director is just €500 a month.

But Valentin Dimitrov, the director until April, managed to live well: making a splash at high-society parties with Elena Tihomirova, Miss Bulgaria 2003, living in a villa worth €400,000, or $506,000, and driving a customized Lexus sport utility vehicle.

After 10 years in the post, through three governments involving all the major political parties, Dimitrov inadvertently provoked the end of his career by seeking in February to raise consumer rates by 12 percent. Continue reading “In Bulgaria, a fleeced public is left in cold”

Bridge to a new era for Bulgaria and Romania

The New York Times

VIDIN, Bulgaria — Construction has not yet begun, but a new bridge over the Danube is already lifting hopes among Bulgarians and Romanians on both sides of the river.

The bridge, which will span the Danube from this downtrodden city to the dusty Romanian town of Calafat, will not just forge new connections, but is also meant to help one of Europe’s least developed regions.

After eight years spent arguing over the location and four years of looking for funding, the €230 million, or $290 million, project is expected finally to enter the construction phase next year thanks to European prodding and finance. Continue reading “Bridge to a new era for Bulgaria and Romania”

Border officials living in opulent villas

The New York Times

STAVRI DIMITROVO, Bulgaria — A powerful illustration of how Bulgarians see border officials living according to separate rules is the so-called “customs officers’ village” here on the Ivailovgrad Reservoir, 30 kilometers from Svilengrad, the town nearest the Kapitan-Andreevo border station. Half of the 40 or so homes in the village are luxurious weekend villas built by former and current border officials and “businessmen.”

The first sight upon entering the village is a hotel-sized mansion on the other side of the reservoir being built by Rumen Atanasov, popularly known as “The Goat,” a hotelier and the former Black Sea representative of Georgi Iliev, a Bulgarian ex-wrestler and organized crime boss who was shot and killed last summer. Continue reading “Border officials living in opulent villas”

In Bulgaria, a porous gateway to EU?

The New York Times

KAPITAN-ANDREEVO, Bulgaria — The spindly observation towers on the Turkish side of this frontier post’s barbed- wire fence stand abandoned, like decaying concrete dinosaurs of a distant Cold War past.

“This border was built to force people to pass through very slowly” from Bulgaria to Turkey, said Nikola Karaivanov, chief of customs at the Kapitan-Andreevo border station. “Now,” he said, “it needs to be changed in the opposite direction” – to control passage into the European Union.

EU officials say that this sprawling border area about 300 kilometers, or 185 miles, southeast of Sofia will soon become one of the EU’s busiest external frontiers: 35 lanes of increasing trade and passenger travel between Turkey and an expanded, 27-member bloc. Continue reading “In Bulgaria, a porous gateway to EU?”

A killing complicates Bulgaria’s EU hopes

The New York Times

SOFIA — Emil Kyulev, one of the richest men in Bulgaria, was being driven to work in Sofia in his BMW sports utility vehicle on Oct. 26 when, shortly after 9:00 a.m., according to the police, he was shot and killed by a man hiding in the bushes.

A few kilometers away, at the moment Kyulev was slain, Bulgaria’s justice and interior ministers were meeting the press to play down a European Union report expressing “serious concerns” about organized crime in the country. The problem, the report noted, “so far has not been a priority on the political agenda.”

Interior Minister Rumen Petkov said the criticism, issued the previous day, was “not a surprise.” Then, as officials learned of the killing, the press conference was abruptly cut short. Continue reading “A killing complicates Bulgaria’s EU hopes”

Thracian Gold Fever

published in Archaeology Magazine Vol 58 Issue 2

Archaeologist and showman Georgi Kitov’s spectacular discoveries raise questions about managing Bulgaria’s past.

On a soft, gray fall afternoon, a crowd of several hundred waited patiently outside the Iskra History Museum in Kazanluk, the unprepossessing main town in central Bulgaria’s rose-growing region. The blank concrete facade of the museum, like that of most Communist-era cultural institutions, created a notably joyless impression.

But inside, the 15 visitors allowed at a time into the small exhibition hall were awed by fantastic Thracian gold, silver, bronze, and ceramic objects, 28 in all, recently discovered only eight miles away and on public display for the first time. An ancient amphora housed on a wobbly metal stand rocked ominously as a woman brushed by. The excitement of the visitors washed over the tiny provincial museum as they carefully studied the objects that have been heralded across the world. Continue reading “Thracian Gold Fever”

Pagans fight for divine rights of old Greek gods in Greece

Scotland on Sunday

Sun 21 Sep 2003

Pagans fight for divine rights of old Greek gods

MATTHEW BRUNWASSER IN LITOCHORO, GREECE

IN THE shadow of Mount Olympus the toga-clad worshippers sway to the
beating of a drum as the bearded man leading the ceremony throws a pinch of
grain into a torch, then circles his hand above the flames.

While the group, dressed in yellow, red and blue robes, may appear to be
taking part in some bewildering historical re-enactment, they are members a
growing pagan movement dedicated to resurrecting the religion and way of
life of ancient Greece. Continue reading “Pagans fight for divine rights of old Greek gods in Greece”

Exiles bring Greek guilt home

“‘Laws still prevent Pomaks living outside their traditional villages’”

Published Date: 07 September 2003
By MATTHEW BRUNWASSER IN THESSALONIKI

THEY were sent into exile and scattered to every corner of the world. For more than half a century the Macedonian Diaspora cast out of Greece during the country’s bloody civil war have been barred from returning to their homeland.

Now the army of elderly refugees has been granted a temporary homecoming, if not the return of the money and property seized during the savage conflict that pitted them against their fellow countrymen.

Greece is finally facing up to its history of ‘ethnic cleansing’ and beginning the process of extending full rights to its minorities, who faced decades of persecution and discrimination under successive oppressive regimes and right-wing dictatorships. Continue reading “Exiles bring Greek guilt home”

© 2000-2025 Matthew Brunwasser | Theme: Baskerville 2

Up ↑